UC LMRI's 18th Annual Conference:
Language Rights and the Education of English Learners

We hope to see you at the
19th Annual Conference
May 5-6, 2006!
(location TBA)

Check out the Post-Conference Info page for a selection of presenter materials and to view the conference Photo Gallery.

Questions? Problems?
Call us at (805) 893-2250

UC LMRI Home

Special Note to Mac users: If you do not have the full version of Adobe Acrobat installed on your computer, you will need to download the free Adobe Reader (version 7.0) to use any of the fillable forms on this web site.

LIST OF PRESENTERS (in alphabetical order)
For order of appearance, please see the 2005 Conference Program

Presenter/Co-Presenter(s)
Title
Abstract

Jeanette Bicais, CSU East Bay

co-presenter:
Manuel G. Correia
, San Francisco Unified School District

What's culture got to do with it? Literacy development in sociocultural contexts

This presentation will share the findings from two dissertations conducted at UC Berkeley employing qualitative research. The studies took place in linguistically and culturally diverse elementary schools, one being a two-way immersion Spanish classroom, and the other in several classrooms where the focal children, comprising different home languages, had been identified as remedial.

The focus was on how children incorporated their peer and home culture in official and unofficial spaces to create written texts. Within these spaces for writing, children interacted and developed a more complex view of self thereby reflecting the complexities of their peer relationships and home lives.

Implications for teachers of English Learners include the importance of designing spaces for children to interact while writing in order to foster children's understanding of classroom writing practices. In this way, teachers may promote dialogue that bridges multiple home resources to school discourses.

George Bunch, UC Santa Cruz
What's culture got to do with it? Literacy development in sociocultural contexts

It is widely accepted that language minority students must learn "academic English" to succeed in U.S. schools, but how to define the term has been a matter of debate.

In this paper, I argue that in order to understand the nature of academic language, we must begin by examining the experiences of real students engaged in real school tasks. I report on the ways that 7th grade students working in linguistically heterogeneous groups used language to complete social studies projects in one predominantly Latino California middle school. Results indicate that academic language cannot be understood as a simple dichotomy between "academic" and "everyday" language.

I connect this research to language rights, in terms of students' right to use home languages and "non-academic" varieties of English in the service of their academic work, as well as their right to assistance in developing uses of English typically called for in school.

Patricia Caldera, UC San Francisco

co-presenters:
Claudia Scharff
, UC San Francisco
Gloria Rodriguez Bañuelos, Stanford University

Quattro Alliance for Science and Language Integration

A novel multi-tiered professional development program, Quattro Alliance for Science and Language Integration, brings together four groups of participants, elementary school teachers from the San Francisco Unified School District (SFUSD), scientists and clinicians from the University of California San Francisco (UCSF), elementary school English Language Learning (ELL) students from SFUSD, and a collaborative of evaluators to: 1) explore relationships between science learning and language development through scientist-teacher partnerships, 2) increase access to rigorous science learning for ELL students, 3) generate knowledge of strategies for integrating science and language learning through engaging all participants in a professional community.

The Science Education Partnership Award (SEPA) from the National Research Resources of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) funds this program.

Daniel Choi, Arizona State University

co-presenter:
Stefan Rosenzweig, Center for Language Minority Education and Research

Language wrongs in Arizona and why Californians should be concerned

For the past two decades the ruling in Castañeda v. Pickard, adopted by OCR, has set a three-pronged test to provide a minimal amount of protection to English Learners. Litigation in California has been unsuccessful in overturning Prop. 227 on the basis of the first Castañeda prong. Litigation in Arizona now threatens to emasculate the second prong.

The court in Flores v. Arizona has recently ruled that a teacher who completes a mere 15 hours of training is qualified to teach English language learners. This is of course woefully inadequate according to the most reliable research. In this workshop we will discuss the current state of federal law and activities in Arizona which inevitably has implications for California as both states operate under the jurisdiction of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit

Tamara Daley, UCLA

Presenting on UC LMRI Research Grant #02-02CY-07DG-LA

Language and Communication among Cambodian American Youth and Parents: Relationship to Youth Mental Health

Cambodians residing in Los Angeles county have been identified as an extremely vulnerable population. On nearly every indicator of social and economic adjustment, Cambodians rank below other ethnic groups, characterized by a poverty level of nearly 50%, living in clusters of low-income, high-crime neighborhoods, and low English proficiency and education levels in adults. Compounding the social and economic challenges for this community are significant mental health problems among adults as a result of their experiences under the Khmer Rouge regime. These adults are parents to a new generation of Cambodian youth, born in the U.S., and it is not surprising that parent-child conflict and cultural gaps as well as youth mental health has been identified as one of the newest challenges for the community.

This dissertation explored mental health issues among the second-generation Cambodian youth in this community, with particular focus on both youth and parent explanatory models of mental health problems and perceptions of parent-child communication. By using a sample drawn from a clinic population and a matched community control group, comparisons are made between children already identified as having mental health needs and those who are not.

In this presentation, I will present selected findings that highlight the potential significance of perceptions of communication as it relates to youth symptoms of internalizing and externalizing problems. I will also highlight the particular challenges related to language proficiency and language use among parents and children in this community, and how parent and youth report of language ability relates to communication and symptomology in children.

Begoña Echeverria, UC Riverside
Language policies and practices in the Basque Autonomous Community: Implications for English learners in California

This paper discusses educational language policies in the Basque Autonomous Community of Spain, and their implications for English learners in California.

I show that educational efforts to revitalize Basque have: 1) increased its use and prestige, though Spanish continues to dominate; 2) increased use of Basque by young women, because most jobs requiring Basque are female-dominated and because Basque can be used to construct a sophisticated feminine identity for the first time.

This research suggests that educational policies designed for English learners in California: 1) should examine the social meanings ascribed native languages and English, not just thier instrumental value; 2) should attend to the gender ideologies attached to language varieties inside and outside the school; and 3) should take into account that, to the extent that jobs associated with English are gendered, male and female English learners might differ in their attitudes toward and efforts to learn English.

Liz Galvin, UC Los Angeles

co-presenter:
Sandra Staklis, Stanford University

Changing Definitions of Language Rights in Latvia

Our presentation will explore changes in the definition of language rights in the post-Soviet Republic of Latvia. While the current state language of Latvia is Latvian, there is a sizeable minority of Russian speakers (30%). Reforms have ensured the position of Latvian as the language of state-funded education.

We will discuss the way that stakeholders, both pro-and anti-reform, have used linguistic human rights arguments to bolster their case. We will also discuss the implications of this reform for higher education: are language rights applicable to higher ed? Why or why not?

Patricia Gandara, UC Davis/LMRI

Presentation on the forthcoming report:

“Listening to the Voices of Teachers of English Learners”

(Abstract)
Jorge Garcia, Boulder Valley School District
Defeating an Anti-Bilingual Education Initiative by Building Activist Coalitions

In 2002 an anti-bilingual education voter initiative was imported to Colorado from California. The same sponsor of California's Proposition 227, Arizona's Proposition 203, and Massachussetts' Question 2, proposed Amendment 31 in Colorado. Using the issues of language rights and language policy at the state and local levels and leveraging the grassroots power of activist groups a coalition of educators, lawmakers, policy makers, parents, students, activists, and other stakeholders were able to defeat the anti-bilingual education measure. No other similar statewide initiative has been able to achieve the same results.

This session will address the lessons learned, the power that language policy wielded in creating a successful coalition, and how the defeat of Amendment 31 has led to subsequesnt legal and political victories.

The presenter was intimately involved with the entire effort and was a litigant in 2 Colorado Supreme Court cases that addressed the legal issues.

Michael Gerber, UC Santa Barbara

co-presenters:
Chris Cate, UC Santa Barbara
Ingrid Salamanca, UC Santa Barbara

Presenting on UC LMRI Research Grant Longitudinal Study "La Patera"

Continuing Longitudinal Study of EL Students Acquisition of Reading

La Patera is a longitudinal study currently in its fifth year. English Learners (ELs) began in kindergarten and are now in fourth grade, struggling with content-area reading. Currently the assessment package of phonological awareness, memory, reading and reading comprehension assessments is being administered.

Analyses will include both the relationship between these measures and an investigation of predictive relationships of kindergarten pre-reading and early word reading data with current fourth grade outcome measures. Furthermore, a sub-study will investigate how well an instrument designed to concurrently measure reading comprehension and memory, correlates with standardized measures of both reading comprehension and memory by comparing test differences between a fourth grade class of English students with a class of ELs.

The instructional component of these students will be addressed by comparing teacher beliefs about instructing ELs and their instructional behaviors in classroom

Panayota Gounari, University of Massachusetts Boston
The Politics of Intolerance: US Language Policy in Process

The current assault on languages other than English--ranging from referenda in various states to vote out Bilingual Education, to the elimination of Title VII, to the punishment of teachers who dare to use languages other than English in their classrooms--marks an important turn in the politics of language policy in the United States. Never before, after the civil rights movement, has the legislative narrative been so blatantly exclusionary and racist in terms of languages other than English.

While the United States has had no overt official language policy regulated by legal and constitutional declaration, yet it has been the envy of many nations that aggressively police language use within their borders through explicit policies designed to protect the "purity" and "integrity" of the national language. They are envious that even without a rigid policy, the United States has managed to achieve such a high level of monolingualism that speaking a language other than English constitutes a real liability.

American monolingualism is part and parcel of an assimilationist ideology that decimated the American indigenous languages as well as the many languages brought to this shore by various waves of immigrants.

As the mainstream culture felt threatened by the presence of multiple languages--which were perceived as competing with English--the reaction by the media, educational institutions, and government agencies was to launch periodic assaults on languages other than English. This was the case with American-Indian languages during the colonial period and German during the first and second world wars.

The covert assimilationist language policy in the United States has been so successful in the creation of an ever-increasing linguistic xenophobia that it "legitimated" the existence of such movements as the English-Only or English for the Children, that promote a racist agenda for English only instruction in schools.

In my presentation I will look into the effects of linguistic policies (and especially the passing of Proposition 2 in Massachusetts to abolish Bilingual Education) in the education and lives of linguistic minority students.

Sehee Hong (grantee, not presenting), UC Santa Barbara

co-presenter:
Sukkyung You, UC Santa Barbara

Presenting on UC LMRI Research Grant #03-03CY-10IG-SB

Latent Growth Mixture Modeling of Language-Minority Latino Children's Growth in Mathematics Achievement

The challenge of serving language minority students in U.S. schools is a major focal point in educational research.

Latinos have been the fastest growing minority group in the school-age population over the last several decades (U.S. Department of Education, 2000). However, Latino children represent the poorest and least educated of minority groups and are associated with underachievement in U.S. schools (Lopez & Cole, 1999).

In this study, we tested if there are distinct growth patterns (e.g., high, middle, and low groups) in Latino children's mathematics growth using the newly released Early Childhood Longitudinal Study dataset. Latent growth mixture analyses show that there are four different mathematics developmental profiles. Further, we attempted to identify important factors that are positively or negatively related to successful outcomes in mathematics achievement among Latino children.

Results show that when the language of instruction and home language is English, the probability of being in the highest performing group increases.

Tom Humphries (grantee, not presenting), UC San Diego

co-presenter:
Bobbie Allen, UC San Diego

Presenting on UC LMRI Research Grant #02-02CY-01TG-SD

Portraits of Literacy: Deaf Children As Readers and Writers

Bilingual classrooms for deaf children using American Sign Language (ASL) as a primary language are rare, but numbers are increasing. Controversy about the effectiveness of ASL-English bilingual practices for deaf children exists.

Constraints based on current legislation have not prevented classroom teachers from implementing bilingual practices, yet, there has been very little research identifying effective practices. Thus, a collaborative partnership with bilingual teachers, pre-service teachers in the Master's program at the University of California, San Diego's Teacher Education Program and faculty was established.

The results of the 2-year project were identification, description and/or implementation of: (1) effective practices, (2) authentic assessment tool, (3) "The ASL Scale of Development" and, (4) literacy strategies/behaviors used by bilingual deaf children.

Some of the findings will be presented as well as practical lessons learned about deaf children as readers and writers that may be applicable across bilingual settings.

Sarah Jones, UC Santa Barbara

Presenting on UC LMRI Research Grant #03-03CY-02DG-SB

Studying "Success" at an "Effective" School: How a Nationally Recognized Public School Overcomes Racial, Ethnic, and Social Boundaries and Creates a Culture of Success

The Knowledge is Power Program, KIPP, is a public charter school that includes fifth through eighth grade. Seventy-nine percent of the students who attend KIPP are Hispanic (sixty to sixty-five percent of whom come from non-native English speaking families), seventeen percent are African American, and ninety percent participate in federal breakfast and lunch programs. For a school with such a population, a high percentage of low-income, minority students, one might expect rather dismal oucomes. However, KIPP is one of the highest performing middle schools in Texas. This dissertation examines how KIPP's culture contributes to its effectiveness.

In the first portion of my dissertation I argue that KIPP's effectiveness can, in part, be attributed to the ways in which they define success. Not only does the school utilize a set of definitions that rely upon outcomes to publicly demonstrate their success, but they also evoke a private, "backstage" definition of success that empowers students by giving them a sense of agency

In the second portion of my dissertation I argue that in order to understand KIPP's "successes" one must locate and define their school culture. Here I introduce the method by which I locate KIPP culture in the "doing of discipline" and their process of socialization. In the final portion of my dissertation I show how the four key cultural schemas at KIPP, the notions of choice, team and family, hard work, high expectations with no excuses, guide the structures, practice, and beliefs at KIPP.

Peter Kuhn (grantee, not presenting), UC Santa Barbara

co-presenter:
Fernando Lozano, UC Santa Barbara

Presenting on UC LMRI Research Grant #03-03CY-09IG-SB

Language, High School Leadership and the Postsecondary Outcomes of Hispanic Students

This paper asks whether high school leadership activities play an important role in the educational success of Hispanic students. In particular, can differences in these activities help explain in the Hispanic college-completion gap?

This paper addresses two specific questions: first, do Hispanic high school students participate in high school leadership activities at the same rate as their Non-Hispanic counterparts? Second, do Hispanic students benefit as much from high school leadership activities as non-Hispanic students, in terms of both, the type of college first attended and in the probability of obtaining a four-year degree?

This analysis considers the role that English language fluency plays in a Hispanic students' leadership probability and in the student's future educational success.

Lorena Llosa, UC Los Angeles

Presenting on UC LMRI Research Grant #04-04CY-03DG-LA

Validating the use of a standards-based classroom assessment of English proficiency

This study investigates the validity of the inferences drawn from a standards-based classroom assessment of English proficiency used to make high-stakes decisions about English learners in a large urban school district in California.

Two approaches were employed: 1) examining the classroom assessment in relation to another measure of the same ability„the California English Language Development Test (CELDT)„using a confirmatory factor analysis model of multitrait multimethod data; and 2) examining the processes teachers engaged in while scoring the classroom assessment using verbal protocol analysis.

Findings from the quantitative and qualitative approaches will be discussed in term of their implications for the use of standards-based classroom assessments within a high-stakes accountability system.

Molly Loomis, UC Santa Cruz

co-presenter:
Doris Ash, UC Santa Cruz

Questions as Resources for English Learners in Science Conversations

With nearly a quarter of students entering California schools as English learners (CADOE), it is critical to understand the resources that these students bring to classroom learning. Studies in science education also need to focus on how voices from multiple perspectives relate to the field of science, and how science can come to include these voices.

This study explores the linguistic resources that Mexican-Descent, Head Start English learners bring to science learning in informal environments. Using both discourse analysis (Nystrand, 2001, Wells, 2001) and a naturalistic paradigm (Moschkovitch & Brenner, 2000), we explore the role questions play in collaborative dialogue in a marine biology discovery center. Preliminary findings suggest that questions contribute to productive dialogue and scaffold families’ scientific making meaning.

We hope our analysis helps us understand the resources that learners from all backgrounds bring to out-of-school settings, and contributes to a view of learning across settings.

Susan O'Hara, CSU Sacramento

co-presenters:
Robert Pritchard, CSU Sacramento
Richard Duran, UC Santa Barbara

Using Hypermedia Environments to Promote Vocabulary Development in Multiple Languages

Researchers in literacy education have articulated the need for all students to become more familiar with learning in hypermedia and web-based environments (Cummins, 2005; Leu et. al, 2005). In addition these environments can offer students primary language support. In this presentation we will discuss some of the research on vocabulary development and the benefits of using hypermedia environments to enhance vocabulary development in multiple languages.

We will also present the results from a recent study conducted by the presenters which investigated the impact of hypermedia authoring on the academic vocabulary development of a seventh grade ESL classroom.

Ross Parke(grantee, not presenting), UC Riverside

co-presenter:
Eric Vega, UC Riverside

Presenting on UC LMRI Research Grant #02-02CY-03IG-R

The Role of Student and Parent Perceptions in the Educational Achievement of Language Minority Students: A Qualitative Approach

Surprisingly little is known about how economic resources, cultural background, immigration status, language proficiency, parenting practices, and school environments combine to affect Mexican American children's academic aspirations, school transitions and educational achievement.

Because Latino youth are twice as likely to be behind in school or drop out of school as non-minority students, and they are less likely to pursue postsecondary education, it is critical to understand the social, cultural, and familial factors that influence a wide range of school-related outcomes.

To better understand the antecedents of educational attainment for Mexican American language minority students, we conducted individual, open-ended qualitative interviews with 54 8th grade students, 53 of their mothers, and 45 of their fathers.

Our analyses of these transcribed interviews indicated that a variety of agents need to be considered in order to better understand individual achievement issues in minority samples. Parental factors, including level of education, hopes and expectations for their children's educational attainment, and type and extent of parental involvement were all revealed by our interviewees to be important factors in shaping children's expectations and in keeping them on track to achieve academic success.

Both parents and children pointed to the role of parents in helping with homework, enforcing rules about doing homework, and stressing the importance of good grades for future success in attending college and developing a career. Second, teachers were seen as important players in children's academic success, especially in terms of motivating them or discouraging them from trying hard in school. Third, peers were found to play important roles as well, with avoidance of unmotivated peers seen as an effective strategy for maintaining high levels of academic achievement.

We discovered that many parents and children relied on social comparison processes that were family centered. Children tended to cite their parents' strong work ethic as a motivation for them to work hard in school, and sometimes other family members such as uncles or cousins were used as positive models to emulate or negative examples to avoid. Parents' educational aspirations for their children were limited by their own lack of understanding of the educational system, especially beyond high school. Even though they embraced the objectives of the school and of their children's teachers, most of these parents had little direct experience with advanced education and few ideas about how to foster academic success.

Two potentially important parental sentiments related to the academic achievement of their children that emerged from the interviews were children's happiness and the concept of child choice in educational and occupational domains. Parents who viewed college as optional tended to focus on their children's future happiness as their primary goal, whereas those who assumed that their children would attend college tended to invoke longer range goals and to focus on future opportunities. Parents who emphasized their children's happiness also tended to frame academic achievement and college plans as a child choice rather than as a parental or family-level decision.

Our findings suggest that targeted counseling programs aimed at better informing Mexican American parents and adolescents about their educational and occupational options, and the intricacies of balancing academic achievement and family obligations, could prove worthwhile.

Luis O. Reyes, Bronx Institute, Lehman College New York City's Aspira Consent Decree: Thirty Years of Struggle and Accomplishment

The Aspira Consent Decree of 1974 mandated the New York City Board of Education to provide bilingual education programs to Puerto Rican and other Latino students.

The presentation embeds the Consent Decree in the historic struggle of the Puerto Rican community in New York City for equal educational opportunity and bilingual/bicultural education. The Decree is also analyzed in the context of the contemporaneous Lau v. Nichols Supreme Court decision of 1974.

Significant historical markers of the 30-year struggle include attacks on and defense of the Decree, an analysis of the accomplishments, and recommendations for a 21st century multilingual coalition to actualize the principles of equity, adequacy and excellence.

Maria Estela Zarate, UC Los Angeles

Presenting on UC LMRI Research Grant #04-04CY-01DG-LA

What do schools have to do with it? The role of Latinas' schooling experiences in college enrollment

This longitudinal study finds that English-language acquisition context and school agents play a very important role in Latinas college enrollment outcomes, more so than academic performance.

When the study began in 1989, two school districts were represented in the sample. Fifteen years later, it is apparent that the girls English language acquisition trajectory and reading performance (1st … 10th grade) varied by school district and this influenced the college enrollment outcomes and college destinations of the girls. Teachers ratings of the students and their relations with students also developed differently for the non-college and college girls.

The student-teachers relationships in this study are complex, span the entire schooling experience of the students, and have important consequences to college enrollment.